SurveyMonkey Powered Online Survey

I'm Tim Kane, a research fellow at Stanford University and also a fan of college football. I was surprised by the play calling & review process in the CFP playoff games, so put together this academic study into bias and accuracy, which I hope is fun as well! Take a look at these close calls from recent college football bowl games. What do you think are the right calls?

CFP Championship -- LSU vs. Clemson, January 13, 2020

Question Title

* Q1 - 8:39

Clean play, no penalty

Blind side block

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q3 - 6:02

Clean play, no penalty

Personal Foul: Targeting

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q4 - 11:18

Clean play, no penalty

Offensive Pass Interference

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Fiesta Bowl -- Ohio State vs. Clemson, December 28, 2019

Question Title

* Q1 - 13:13

Catch (pass complete)

Incomplete Pass

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q2 - 14:17 *

Touchdown

Incomplete Pass

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q2 - 5:00 *

Personal Foul: Targeting

Clean play. No penalty.

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q3 - 8:31 *

Penalty: Roughing the kicker, which is a personal foul

Penalty: Running into the kicker

No Penalty

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Question Title

* Q3 - 5:00 *

Complete pass & fumble

Incomplete pass

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

Citrus Bowl -- Alabama vs. Michigan, January 1, 2020

Question Title

* Q2 4:15

Personal Foul: Roughing the passer

Clean Play

Neutral / Unclear from the video replay

33% of survey complete.