1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues.
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. Unsatisfactory
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. Fair
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. Satisfactory
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. Very Good
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. Excellent
1. Ability to identify and analyze relevant issues. N/A
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules.
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. Unsatisfactory
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. Fair
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. Satisfactory
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. Very Good
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. Excellent
2. Judgment in application of relevant laws and rules. N/A
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed.
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. Unsatisfactory
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. Fair
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. Satisfactory
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. Very Good
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. Excellent
3. Giving reasons for rulings, when needed. N/A
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings.
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. Unsatisfactory
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. Fair
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. Satisfactory
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. Very Good
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. Excellent
4. Clarity of explanation of rulings. N/A
5. Adequacy of findings of fact.
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. Unsatisfactory
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. Fair
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. Satisfactory
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. Very Good
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. Excellent
5. Adequacy of findings of fact. N/A
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written).
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). Unsatisfactory
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). Fair
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). Satisfactory
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). Very Good
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). Excellent
6. Clarity of judge's decision (either oral or written). N/A
7. Completeness of judge's decision.
7. Completeness of judge's decision. Unsatisfactory
7. Completeness of judge's decision. Fair
7. Completeness of judge's decision. Satisfactory
7. Completeness of judge's decision. Very Good
7. Completeness of judge's decision. Excellent
7. Completeness of judge's decision. N/A
8. Punctuality.
8. Punctuality. Unsatisfactory
8. Punctuality. Fair
8. Punctuality. Satisfactory
8. Punctuality. Very Good
8. Punctuality. Excellent
8. Punctuality. N/A
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding.
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. Unsatisfactory
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. Fair
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. Satisfactory
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. Very Good
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. Excellent
9. Resourcefulness and common sense in resolving problems arising during the proceeding. N/A
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals.
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. Unsatisfactory
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. Fair
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. Satisfactory
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. Very Good
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. Excellent
10. Credibility of the judge's settlement appraisals. N/A
11. Decisiveness.
11. Decisiveness. Unsatisfactory
11. Decisiveness. Fair
11. Decisiveness. Satisfactory
11. Decisiveness. Very Good
11. Decisiveness. Excellent
11. Decisiveness. N/A